Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Our attention is misplaced

...if you drive one of the Toyotas recalled for acceleration problems and don’t bother to comply with the recall, your chances of being involved in a fatal accident over the next two years because of the unfixed problem are a bit worse than one in a million—2.8 in a million, to be more exact. Meanwhile, your chances of being killed in a car accident during the next two years just by virtue of being an American are one in 5,244.
– Robert Wright

Thursday, March 11, 2010

The New Depression, Part II

back to part one...

As it stands today, we've seen fantastic technological developments in the past decade in the way information is handled. This is something that can benefit every industry. But, it tends to effect each industry in the grunt-work positions: jobs that handle the processing of information but little responsibility to make decisions. Jobs that now can be automated. In short, entry-level jobs.

At the helm to receive these jobs is a generation that is best equipped to make them easier for themselves: they already understand the tools that make it easier. Why spend hours tabulating data from a paper form, when you can automate the whole process of data collection and calculation on a Google Document?

This knowledge, unfortunately, has not been to this generation's advantage. They are increasingly derided as lazy and "dislike[ing] the idea of work for work’s sake, and expect[ing] jobs and career to be tailored to their interests and lifestyle." The fact that this generation has been increasingly beginning their post-collegiate years living with their parents again is occasionally described as a cause of their employment woes rather than an effect.

The result is that the jobs this generation streamlines are then eliminated, self-defeatingly. And evidence supports that when you enter the job market in a recession or difficult hiring environment, the effect on your whole career is permanent, and make you disproportionately susceptible to depression.

The point of this matter, however, is that we are again in a situation in which technology has displaced human labor, and we have not yet figured out what kind of work will fill the employment gap in our economy. The path we are currently on of great inequality would lead us to a likely solution of more guarding and destructive work. But this doesn't have to be the way capitalism operates.

What if a system were devised in which the technological benefits that have made work easier were actually to the benefit of people who do the work? If people were encouraged, when technology made their work easier, to do less of it (instead of find other work to maintain a 40 hour work week to keep your health benefits)? What if labor-saving technology actually increased leisure time?

What if, as Sam Bowles suggests, there was a universal welfare system that didn't disappear if you found work, thus disincentivizing employment? His suggestion is enough to live a meager existence on if you wanted, but if you were ambitious, could be put toward going to college or starting a business?

What if such a system was funded by putting a just price on natural resources through carbon and land taxes?

What we have today in the United States doesn't have to be what capitalism is.

The New Depression, Part I

From a CNN/Opinion Research Corporation poll:
  1. 40% of people are satisfied with the way democracy is working in this country
  2. 59% are dissatisfied
Personally, I share some of the feelings of your Wonkette's commentary:
Why? Well, if you’re on the side of Obama’s big majority of 2008 and the even bigger Dem majorities in the Senate and House, you’re probably a little “let down” that a handful of wingnut rural senators (Ben Nelson, etc.) representing a tiny fraction of the population have somehow stopped all the shit you supported, like health care reform. WTF, right? And you probably never really got over that whole deal in 2000 when the Republican-controlled Supreme Court of the United States appointed somebody president even though this person lost the election. Ouch! Ha ha, and then we had eight straight years of horror and blood, and then the entire economy collapsed. Again. And if you are an angry unemployed uneducated middle-aged rural/southern white person, what is up with a negro becoming president?! That’s not in the *original* Constitution, right?

The question asked about our current state of democracy. We all hope, though, that this democracy – whether we believe it will be through government shrinking or growing, through social programs or through tax cuts – is supposed to make our lives better.

This democracy has, however, in the past thirty or so years allowed a peculiar sort of capitalism to thrive. Michael Scherer describes it thusly:

America's greatest successes for the past decade have come largely from destruction--the company that closes a plant to ship jobs overseas, the financial wizard who predicted a mortgage market collapse created by other financial wizards, the corporate executive who has figured out how to do more with less. We are all living through an age of contraction, in which smart destruction is more prized than creation. I don't know where it is leading us, but I would be willing to wager on the skills that next year's Harvard and Yale grads dream about acquiring. No doubt that America will soon be home to the most skilled and accomplished destroyers in history. As you tuck your children in tonight, let them know. If they dream big, they too can one day dismantle something wonderful.

Does the wealth earned in this context represent reward for benefiting the citizens of this economy?

According to research by Samuel Bowles at the Santa Fe Institute, America's economy today is one in which a quarter of the employed are what he considers "guard labor":

The job descriptions of guard labor range from "imposing work discipline"—think of the corporate IT spies who keep desk jockeys from slacking off online—to enforcing laws, like the officers in the Santa Fe Police Department paddy wagon parked outside of Walmart. The greater the inequalities in a society, the more guard labor it requires, Bowles finds.

Does the wealth earned by guard labor represent reward for benefiting the citizens of this economy?

Capitalism in America is a structure in which, essentially, everyone must spend whatever they earn to keep everyone else employed. If people start to save too much, spending a little less on non-essential goods, perhaps, those people who work in the business of making those non-essential goods will begin to lose their jobs. If anyone then starts to worry that their industry could be next, they start saving money in case catastrophe strikes, and then, of course, more industries do take a hit.

All of this occurs in a context of constant technological advancement. Since the industrial revolution, machines have been replacing work that was previously done by humans. In order to keep the economy alive, we must create new work for the people who've been displaced. Things like guard labor. Things like destructive labor.

to part two...

Monday, March 8, 2010

I had occasion to remember...

Robert Newman's History of Oil is entertaining, true, and important. Anyone who hasn't seen it should set aside 45 minutes to do so (as its only detriment is it happens to be a little long).

Reconsidering taxes

It would not surprise the reader to learn that I'm generally in favor of public reinterpretation of taxes and taxation. The joke goes that a republican can't say "tax" without "cut," and that a democrat can't say "tax" without "on the rich," and this sort of vastly undercuts what should be understood as a public good.

Jeremy Adam Smith has some interesting commentary on this. He describes his local faltering infrastructure and laments the inadequacy of the currently defined tax base. His home of San Francisco is in particular trouble what with the state of California capping property tax at 1%. It is interesting that he does not mention this, given that most of the public goods that he mentions as depending on taxation are location-based: schools, libraries, public transit – mind you, I'm very optimistic about reducing the location-dependence of public education and information, but at the moment, most people's education is still determined very largely by where they live. Smith's personal connection with the dismal situation regarding public taxation is he just did his taxes, presumably income taxation – another odd disconnect.

He goes into detail about public transit, and cites a study [pdf] that illustrates fantastically what kind of public good a usable transit system is:

Providing high quality public transit service typically requires about $268 in annual subsidies and $108 in additional fares per capita, but reduces vehicle, parking and road costs an average of $1,040 per capita. For an average household this works out to $775 annually in additional public transit expenses and $2,350 in vehicle, parking and roadway savings, or $1,575 in overall net savings, in addition to other benefits including congestion reductions, reduced traffic accidents, pollution emission reductions, improved mobility for non-drivers, and improved public fitness and health.

The value of that savings is reflected in the value of the property that is serviced by such a transit system – which is to say that unless that fifteen hundred dollars is recollected in property taxes, landowners are given a handout.

But the important point is: this transit service costs significantly less than than the value it produces. The local government would not need to recollect all the land value it created to fund the transit services that create it. It could be argued that the government would have the right to, because they created the value and not the landowner, but if it were to do so, a legitimate government of the people would in turn return such value to its citizens equally, not just to the landowners.

If one must call the people recollecting the value they created a "tax," then so be it.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Small Request

Robert Gibbs should go into the press room and say something like the following:
Just in case we haven't been clear: deficit spending in a recession is actually a strategy, a deliberate strategy. It is not a sloppy mistake we are making in which we've just decided to spend with no regard for what amount of money is coming in.

You may disagree with this strategy. The other major strategy to stimulate the economy is for the Fed to lower the interest rate, but it's already at zero. We all like that option, too, but for this recession it's not enough.

You may think a tax cut is better to stimulate the economy than government spending. Most data supports the idea that government spending is better, but because a good portion of the American people prefer tax cuts, we made 280 billion of the stimulus package a tax cut for 95% of working Americans. But still, we have to increase the deficit to either cut taxes or spend, and that's the point.

We are making this point to rebut anyone who argues that the deficit at this point is irresponsible. Deficit spending is how we got out of the Great Depression. Deficit spending is how Reagan got us out of the 1980 recession (only he forgot to reduce the deficit when he was done). And deficit spending is what's going to get us out of this recession.

My guess is, it's what everyone in the White House and the Council of Economic Advisors is thinking, they're just afraid to say it in public. I suppose they could throw in something about how every president between FDR and Obama has lowered the debt, except for Reagan and the Bushes.